We remember most, if not all of these. Jeff the killer, Sonic.exe, Max and ruby 0004, Ben DROWNED, and more, we have a soft spot for creepypastas. From masterpieces like MARIO, to abominable ones like The Rugrats theory, everyone has known about this horror genre for a while. So why not make a list about it?
The worst: Lavender town syndrome: I'm sorry, but this one isn't believable in the slightest. Yes, the music is scary, but do you really think kids would really oof themselves because of this? Tails doll: bro this feels like it was written by a child Bad: Username666: This is just one massive jumpscare blood-fest, and you know how I feel about those! Dead bart: The story feels dumb, but it is a bit high quality so i'll give it that. Ok: The Rake: Odd name aside, this feels underwhelming. Slenderman: Never got into this one, and I just see him as a kidnapper that may as well removed Squidward's face in the Faceless creepypasta. Rap rat: C L I C H E S Ben DROWNED: Same reason as Slenderman, although people do see him as scary. I gave it the benefit of the doubt and gave it high Ok. Decent: Jeff the killer: Influential, but others are better. Cupcakes: I find the concept to be pretty spooky and even considered giving it good, but it just feels like a blood-fest. Eyeless jack: I also find the concept to be pretty good, but others are better. Sonic.exe: Influential, and basically gave the standard to gaming creepypastas, like NES Godzilla and I HATE YOU. Herobrine: I find this one to be just a pupil-less Steve that Mojang keeps referencing in their update lists, but I can see why people would be afraid of him. Good: Red mist: Story is good, BUT, it started the hyper-realistic eyes cliche. Smile dog: I find the premise of the story to be confusing, but it's well written. Mouse.avi: Pretty good. Amazing: SCP foundation: Awesome story, great monsters, what more do I need to say? Abandoned by Disney: Underrated. Fight me. The Best: Candle cove: OMG, this is epic! I like it so much, and it's clear why. It's mysterious and feels like a lost episode done right! Happy appy: This is kinda like Candle cove, but better! Story is phenomenal, and is overall a beast! Russian sleep experiment: This kinda feels like something Russia would do, and is overall very scary. Max and ruby 0004: THE BEST ONE, FIGHT ME.
