So i have a theory. I think we’ve all guessed by now that Winter is Mitski’s ‘switched fate.’ But what about Cinnamonpaw? So here’s my theory, that Star could be evil. This isn’t a random guess, I’ve thought about it. Cinnamonpaw has been in the DF for 200 years, and i don’t think the clans can get any older that that, because according to the WC books, cats do begin to fade after a certain amount of time, so that Starclan won’t get too crowded. If Star had been there from around the start of the clans, with Cinnamonpaw, then there is a possibility. Star always keeps their face hidden, maybe so that no one would ever recognise them as an evil from 200 years ago. The outline of one side of them is red, same as when Red looked at mitski’s paws. This could be that Star was supposed to go to the DF, but went to Starclan, switched with Cinnamonpaw. The red outline could have slightly faded over time since they were in Starclan for such a long time. Though the covered face thing could just be that star is just really ugly and they don’t want to be laughed at. But they ARE the leader of Starclan, at least supposedly, so therefore, laughing at them wouldn’t be a great idea. So if this is correct, even though it’s probably not, Mitski would have a hard task ahead of her.
Story, art and characters belong to @CatTheLoaf. Theory is mine:) And sorry to the person who had almost the exact theory, i didn’t try to copy you, i made this b4 seeing your theory, but I do have different reasoning to why Star could be Cinnamonpaw’s switched fate.
