Okay, okay, okay. Maybe I need to calm down. BUT I NEED ANSWERS. Okay, let's back up. Let's actually back up. (@BMT51713, skip over this part for your sanity.) In TPOT 15: - Gaty was erased from existence In TPOT 19: - Gaty was confirmed erased - Barf Bag and Basketball were erased (@BMT51713, resume reading here.) In all seasons of BFDI, the characters, upon dying, retain some sort of memory of being dead (with the POSSIBLE exception of Three, though her confusion might have been because [NOTGONNASAYBECAUSEIALSOWANTTOPROTECTMYOWNSANITY]). So, when Gaty, Barf Bag, and Basketball get brought back, would they have memory of not existing? But then if they don't exist, there is no being to retrain memory. BUT THEN HOW WOULD ANYONE REMEMBER BEING DEAD? I NEED ANSWERS.