Comment a ship from the series Wings of Fire or Warrior Cats below, and I'll rate it out of 5 and add an explanation/review why! ★☆☆☆☆- I would ragequit the series if they got together ★★☆☆☆- How is this a ship...? ★★★☆☆- Okay, but they'd be better off as friends ★★★★☆- It works- not many problems ★★★★★- SOULMATES Starflight x Fatespeaker ★★★☆☆ I'm not super crazy about this one... Starflight never seems to show that much romantic interest in Fatespeaker beyond realizing that her personality is similar to Sunny's, and is even kind of overwhelmed by her at times. To me, she almost felt like a Sunny replacement/downgrade. Despite that, they do have kind of a cute relationship with Fatespeaker's support of him after he's blinded, and they *do* have dragonets together in the future. So, three out of five. Needletail x Alderheart ★★★★☆ I don't really have much to say about this one. From a logical point, their relationship doesn't look like it would work, but they're actually pretty good friends, and have a nice 'opposites attract' thing going. Plus, it's canon that Alderheart had feelings for Needletail, so four out of five. Bluestar x Firestar ★★★☆☆ Bluestar and Firestar have more of a mentor/apprentice relationship (she's literally his mentor at one point), and besides, Bluestar is much older than him and her mental health is terrible for the majority of their time together. She seems to see him as a son, so I just can't see them together romantically. Jayfeather x Stick ★★★★☆ Jayfeather seems to care for his stick more than he could ever love a cat... but I had to remove a star because he did destroy it. Also, it's a stick. Clay x Peril ★★☆☆☆ Peril has an unhealthy attachment style, rampaging insecurities, no sense of consequences, trauma, and psychotic tendencies. She would be terrible for Clay in a relationship, as she pretty much hates his friends (and everyone who comes within a five-mile radius of him and isn't her) and wants to kill them to have him all to herself. Besides this, Clay barely even seems to have any romantic feelings for her at all. The only reason I didn't give this ship 1 star is because Peril genuinely cares about Clay and would never purposefully hurt him in any way. Qibli x Winter ★★★★☆ Okay... I might be a little biased... but I was shipping this so hard when I read the second arc. I honestly feel like this is a better ship than Moonbli or Winterwatcher. Qibli and Winter are both very vibrant characters with defined, opposite personalities that balance each other out very well, better than Moon's personality balances with either of theirs. They have a good dynamic. The star I took off is because both of them have very defined opinions that clash from time to time, and I feel like they'd have a hard time resolving fights. Overall, fantastic couple. Moonwatcher x Carnelian ★★☆☆☆ I think this one would be really cute, but logically it likely wouldn't work very well. Carnelian is very hostile to Moon, and doesn't respect anyone who hasn't fought in the Great War. Their personalities are pretty incompatible and I just don't see Carnelian viewing Moon as a true equal, ever, even if she gained a little more respect for her. She also probably wouldn't trust Moon, and would really dislike her mindreading and be paranoid that Moon was using it on her. Anemone x Tamarin ★☆☆☆☆ Anemone is a jerk. Tamarin deserves better. The end. Blaze x Glacier ★★☆☆☆ Blaze is immature and arrogant, and... along with being much older than her, Glacier doesn't respect her. She's just trying to keep her alliance to benefit her own kingdom, and is infinitely more mature than Blaze. This relationship would just not work, and honestly, Blaze loves herself too much to have room for anyone else. Sundew x Cricket x Willow ★★★☆☆ Sundew x Willow is a really cute couple, and by themselves I'd rate them 4-5 stars. I don't think they would actually consider being in a relationship with Cricket, though, as they've both pledged to only love each other. I think that they're better off as friends with Cricket, hence the 3 stars. Blister x Morrowseer ★★★☆☆ Blister and Morrowseer have a strictly business relationship, and neither of them seem to particular like the other. Despite this, I think they'd have a cool dynamic, as they're both cunning, evil, and self-serving, so it would be interesting to see how a relationship would work out between them. (If one didn't end up murdering the other.) Nevertheless, I don't think that a relationship between them would really work. In the end, they'd both be too self-serving to really value the other person. Umber x Turtle ★★★★☆ Not much to say here. They're both chill guys in the same winglet. They have very similar personalities, and I think they would get along well in a relationship. Cloudtail x Brightheart ★★★★☆ Cloudtail is really sweet and supportive towards Brightheart. I think they have a really wholesome dynamic, and they seem to be made for each other.
@cclaywof for giving me the idea If I don't agree with you, please don't get mad at me! It's just my opinion, and I don't mean to be rude. Continued ratings- Crowfeather x Leafpool ★★☆☆☆ I ship Crowpool. I have an enormous soft spot for it. It literally makes me swoon (as embarrassing at it is to admit it). But logically, this ship is terrible. It was rushed and Crowfeather seems to just see Leafpool as a Feather tail replacement. Plus, they barely stayed together for a day. I liked it when they later became friends, and I still have a hope that their maturity will let them form a healthier relationship in the future. Squirrelflight x Brambleclaw ★★☆☆☆ I haven't read Squirrelflight's Hope, so I don't know what Bramblestar did in that book that made Warriors fans call him abusive, but this relationship is just toxic. Their communication is terrible, and they don't help each other grow at all. In A Starless Clan, they do finally communicate with each other, which is shown to have a huge positive impact on their relationship. In the end, I don't hate this ship, but they both need to make serious changes to make it work. Sorreltail x Brackenfur ★★★★☆ This ship is cute! I like Brackenfur's support of Sorreltail, and the sweet and devoted way they act to each other, and even though Brackenfur is overprotective, I see it as proof of how much he loves her and her kits. Honestly, I don't remember much about it, since it was minor even during the second arc and hasn't really been touched on since, but I remember liking their relationship then. Peacemaker x Strawberry ★★★★☆ OTP (but he also had a wife... so... that's an issue) Darkstalker x Clearsight ★☆☆☆☆ Their relationship is completely unhealthy. Darkstalker manipulated her, lied to her, and even used a spell to affect her free will. I don't care how much he missed her, or how destined they were for each other. This is an absolutely terrible ship.
