1: BROKENSTAR he was only there for a short period of time but he WAS a great villain 2: Mapleshade do I need to explain? 3: Scourge he’s a small adorable cat who is also fierce and I love him and this picture doesn’t do him justice at all 4: Ashfur the fire scene was iconic and (spoiler warning) now he’s the imposter so yes 5: Sol I love sol because he is able to make cats believe things with only his words not his claws and that… REALLY makes him different from all other warrior cat villains. Also I love how he used the eclipse so yes sol.
