========================================= Instructions: ~ Use arrows to navigate (Wow- it's been a while since I've used that code.) ========================================= Criticism: The dark part on parts of the cat, maybe remove them, the environment isn't that dark; maybe instead, make Scratch Cat gradually darker on that side. The lighter color on Scratch Cat's skin is a little too dark, I get that you are trying to make it because of the strong lighting but make it a little bit brighter as Scratch Cat is being bombarded with light. Maybe put some highlights in the eye (just saying you don't have to, this is just my artistic opinion). Overall, this is a great piece of art. One more thing- I mean no offense, but maybe work on making it a bit neater. A bit of advice, maybe watch some tutorials on shading. (Tutorials help a lot.) ========================================= Notes & Credits: ~ Scratch for the Scratch Cat ~ @LiLTakSick09 for the original project and the shading in the original art piece ~ Me (@Celestaea) for the shading on the edited art piece ~ All code by me ~ The thumbnail is also by me ~ Tutorials will help immensely, I myself still use them ~ Similar to you, I used a mouse/touchpad for all of the art I did ~ Have a nice day :) =========================================