This is a theory about Tansypaw. We all know that she (and moonpaw,) is getting a scar, but the question is: how? so here is my theory: Frostface will try to drowned Perfectpaw and Dave will go in after him. But Tansypaw saw it all so she ran to tell the clan. But Frostface catches up to her and attack's her. Why? not just because she was going to tell the clan; because Shiningstream told him to hurt Tansypaw. And why would Frostface listen? 1. Shining is Frost's dad 2. Shining is a Starclan cat But Moonpaw saw what happened. And jumps on Frostface, but Frostface nocks Moonpaw down with his long necccccccccccccccccc and that is how she gets her scar. this theory would explain "The Wolf" because a wolf is a kind of dog and (and this is 97% sure) Frostface is a dog. And this would explain "Why" because Moonpaw will be asking Frostface WHY!
Ranboo for Toph
