hello there basically real cloaky is ACTUALLY in the abandoned timeline, and the cloaky in the carrot leader arc is actually a replacement due to him becoming a reaper, his reaper form was essentially a zombie which isnt supposed to happen, so he is replaced by a copy to fill in the gap that he left so yeah tl;dr cloaky was replaced, this is real cloaky, in the abandoned timeline, he returns
yuki yuuna is a hero 5 stars ~ 6 flowers
