This is what I think would happen if Brick was in All Stars instead of Sam! This is only my second what if, so please feel free to give me feedback in the comments. Also, feel free to give me suggestions for future what ifs! Things to Know: Brick would pretty obviously be on the Heroes team. Since Brick had a great relationship with Zoey, Mike, and Cameron, they invite him to an alliance. But, when Mal comes along, things happen. Brick and Courtney actually get along well, with Brick always respecting Courtney's orders. Brick and Lindsay get along well and talk about fashion together. Brick is weirded out by Sierra but is friendly to her.
ELIMINATION ORDER: Episode 1: "Heroes vs. Villains" Losers: Heroic Hamsters 14th: Lindsay As much as I don't like how she was written this season, I don't see anything changing with her now that Brick is here. Zoey, Mike, Cameron, and Brick would target her, and Courtney and Sierra would as well. Episode 2: "Evil Dread" *Mal takes over Mike* Losers: Villainous Vultures 13th: Lightning I still don't see anything changing now that Brick is here, so he is still out here. Episode 3: "Saving Private Leechball" Losers: Villainous Vultures 12th: Jo I know this is the third time in a row this has happened, but I don't see anything changing with Jo's elimination. But things will change next episode. *Courtney and Duncan swap teams* Episode 4: "Food Fright" Losers: Villainous Vultures *Originally, the Heroic Hamsters only lost because Sam cheated. So, this time, Sam isn't here to cheat, so the Villains will lose* 11th: Heather Gwen and Courtney would want to target Heather and could easily get Alejandro and Scott on their side. So, Heather would be voted off here. Episode 5: "Moon Madness" Losers: Heroic Hamsters 10th: Sierra She would be targeted by Zoey's alliance because Cameron would be annoyed and scared of her delusions and couldn't get anyone to save her. But this is a fake elimination, and Sierra actually swaps to the Villains! Episode 6: "No One Eggspects the Spanish Opposition" Losers: Villainous Vultures 10th: Sierra The Vultures originally lost, and I'm sure they'd lose again even if Heather is replaced with Sierra. So, they decided to vote out Sierra since she was the weakest link and kept obsessing over Cameron from the other team. Episode 7: "Suckers Punched" Losers: Heroic Hamsters 9th: Duncan Gwen would be unhappy with him and just broke up with him, and Courtney would be unhappy with him too. Gwen and Courtney would ask Alejandro and Scott to vote him off, and Alejandro agreed because he could be a huge threat, and Scott just agreed because why not. Episode 8: "You Regatta Be Kidding Me" MERGE Immune: Alejandro 8th: Cameron Since Duncan isn't here to blow up Chris's cottage/mansion, and Mal originally rigged the votes against Cameron, I don't see a reason why that would change. But this time, Cameron is actually eliminated. Episode 9: "Zeek and Ye Shall Find" Immune: Gwen 7th: Alejandro Since Mal would really want Alejandro gone because he was catching on to him, he easily got Brick and Zoey to vote for Alejandro with him. Mal convinced Zoey to talk to Gwen and Courtney to vote for Alejandro as well, and they agreed. Episode 10: "The Obsta-Kill Kourse" Immune: Zoey 6th: Brick Courtney would want to keep both Scott and Gwen around to make sure she is in a good position and wanted to eliminate either Mal or Brick. She decided she wanted to eliminate Brick and got both Gwen and Scott to vote for him. Zoey wanted to eliminate Scott with Mal and Brick, but Mal voted for Brick, and he was eliminated, leaving Zoey confused. Episode 11: "Sundae Muddy Sundae" Immune: Zoey 5th: Courtney I feel like the same thing would happen here, with Mal exposing Courtney's chart. Gwen and Scott would turn against her and vote her off in the elimination. Mal and Zoey would vote her off as well, eliminating her. Episode 12: "The Bold and the Booty-ful" Immune: Zoey 4th/3rd: Gwen/Scott The same thing would happen here, with Gwen being auto eliminated for putting bear poop on Chris's portrait, and Zoey choosing to take Mal to the finale. Episode 13: "The Final Wreck-ining" *Mike takes over Mal* 2nd/1st: Mike/Zoey Final Order: 14th: Lindsay 13th: Lightning 12th: Jo 11th: Heather *Sierra switches teams* 10th: Sierra 9th: Duncan MERGE 8th: Cameron 7th: Alejandro 6th: Brick 5th: Courtney 4th/3rd: Gwen/Scott 2nd/1st: Mike/Zoey
