This is pretty self-explanatory. I'll only be rating ships I've encountered in the series-- So, for example, I won't be rating Tallstar x Jake because I haven't read any of their interactions. Suggest ships to rate in the comments (though, again, I'll only be doing ones I've seen in the books I've read!) 1 = Ew ew ew get it away from me 5 = Meh 10 = YES YES YES YES YES YES --Firestar x Sandstorm: 7.5/10. Sandpaw was a real jerk when Firepaw first met her, and was still a little rude to him even after she got better, but I think after Firestar's Quest they'll have a better relationship. --Firestar x Spottedleaf: 2/10. Idk how old Spottedleaf was when Firepaw met her, but I'm pretty sure it would be too old for him. Also, he didn't even really have a chance to get to know her before she died. --Firestar x Cinderpelt: 1/10. I wish I could give this a 0 out of 10. The age gap is just disgusting-- Fireheart was already almost an adult when Cinderpelt was BORN. Ew. --Firestar x Bluestar: 1/10. Wait, people actually ship this? Well, I looked on the shipping wiki, and apparently some people do. Ew!! Bluestar was already OLD when Firepaw joined ThunderClan as a KITTEN. Not okay. I think Bluestar is more like a mother figure to Firestar. --Graystripe x Silverstream: 7.5/10. I think their relationship was a little rushed, but they were cute together. I like Silverstream. I actually cried when she died, it was really sad. --Firestar x Graystripe: 5/10. I like them better as friends / brothers, but I could see them in a relationship. I think there are better ships for both of them, though. --Ravenpaw x Barley: 10/10. SO WHOLESOME SO ADORABLE I LOVE THEM SM RAVENPAW IS SO CUTE AND BARLEY IS JUST SO CHILL AND RESPECTFUL AND THEY'RE PERFECT FOR EACH OTHER --Brambleclaw x Squirrelflight: 1/10. I haven't seen much of them, but from what I have seen it's a pretty bad couple. First of all, Bramble is WAY too old for her (Bramblekit was born mid-first arc I think, and Squirrelkit was born at the end of Firestar's Quest), and also, I've seen the majority of the fandom say Brambleclaw is @bv$1v3 towards Squilf... I haven't personally seen any of this myself, but I'm sure he gets worse as the arc goes on. --Bluestar x Oakheart: 5/10. I haven't seen that much of them, but from what I've seen, I think they're cute but could have been done better. --Crowfeather x Feathertail: Unsure. I haven't really seen enough of their interactions, though I think Feathertail is a little too old for him. Also, random funny thing I thought of, a ship name for them could be FeatherFeather xD --Leafpool x Mothwing: 8.5/10. Small age gap, but I can let that go because LESBEANS. I haven't seen that much of them but I think they're pretty adorable! --Goldenflower x Tigerstar: Unsure. I don't think much of their interactions are ever really seen in the books, just that they had kits together. --Frostfur x Lionheart: Again, I'm not sure, since we don't really see them interacting that much. --Longtail x Mousefur: 5.5/10. I never really thought of them as a potential couple, more like just friends, but I think it could work. --Squirrelflight x Stormfur: 8/10. Okay, okay, yes, I know I only just started Moonrise, and I gave the other ship from this book an "unsure" because I hadn't seen much of their interactions-- But hear me out. I gave this one such a high rating because Stormfur's a great cat, and I think he could have been a lot better for Squilf than Bramble or Ash. I'm not sure if he'd actually make a good mate for Squilf, but honestly, I'm giving it such a good rating because it seems MUCH better than the other options. Also, is it just me or was Storm's crush on Squilf a forgotten plot point? I never see anyone talking about it, even though they might have made a good ship. Honestly, I'm curious what other people think-- Let me know your opinion on this one! --Brightheart x Cloudtail: 9/10. They're so cute together!! I love how Cloudtail continues to support Brightheart and see her as the beautiful cat she is even after her injury. They're such a sweet couple. --Dustpelt x Ferncloud: 1/10. EWWWW. It's just like Fireheart x Cinderpelt, but WORSE, because these two ACTUALLY GOT TOGETHER and had KITTENS. Also, Dustpelt is around Firestar's age, if not a little younger, and Ferncloud is YOUNGER than CINDERPELT. This is NOT OKAY. --Brightheart x Swiftpaw: 1/10. No. Just no. They're COUSINS. --Bluestar x Yellowfang: 6/10. I could see them together, but I don't think they'd make the best couple. They could be cute if done right, though. --Firestar x Graystripe x Ravenpaw: I don't understand why people feel the need to ship every single member of a friend group together. Also, unrelated but kind of funny, at first I accidentally spelled Graystripe as "Garystripe" Those are all the ones I could think of! Let me know if you can think of more for me to rate!
Edit: I've been getting suggestions for ships that I haven't come across in the books yet (Mainly Crowfeather x Leafpool). I just want to let you know that if you're one of the people that's suggested one of those, I won't be giving my opinion on them until I've gotten to that part in the books! Thanks for your suggestions, though!
